11 ATTACHMENT 04 - Laserfiche WebLink

EXH U NUV 0 IBIT 12010 CITY OF PLEASANTON Pl¢asanton ;-,71 PUNNING DIVISION r C �l t IOn I;+_ litatISM a 20 8 Pleasanton Heritage Assnciatinn Heritage Residence Photos Used with Permission August 23, 2010 Pleasanton Heritage Association's Review of the Proposed Project at 4189 Stanley Street: SEE ADDENDUM ON PAGE TWO REGARDING TREE REMOVAL The proposed project area consists of 52,510 square feet. The plan is proposing 14 single-family homes. The square footage of the homes ranges from the smallest at 1,599 SF to the largest at 1,920 SF. The plan allows for a fire turn around. There are 26 uncovered parking spaces and 5 uncovered guest spaces. Each of the 14 proposed homes has an enclosed double car garage, allowing for an additional 28 parking spaces. Matthew Davis, from the State Department Resources Agency wrote in his evaluation of the existing home at 4189 Stanley: "The existing home at 4189 Stanley is an example of a Craftsman bungalow dating from 1908. Although the home was not built by a master builder, nor does it possess high artistic values, the house at 4189 Stanley Boulevard does have a fair level of integrity. Because it has not been moved, it retains integrity of location. The footprint, form and structure of the house remain unchanged from that shown on the 1929 Sanborn map of the area, and it retains features associated with the Craftsman bungalow style, including multi-light one over one windows, a hipped dormer, deep eaves; a recessed, partial-width porch; asymmetrical massing; and an exterior chimney. Despite its non-original cladding, the house retains integrity of feeling and association, because it continues to convey a sense of the early twentieth century residential construction in the Pleasanton area." The recommendation of Pleasanton Heritage Association is to make every effort to renovate and retain this house. Although it does not represent the