20 - Laserfiche WebLink

Shyamal Gurazada, neighbor, questioned why the current CUP was not being implemented given there was a unanimous decision in the past. Chabad is a religious institution that wants to use the property for social gatherings and religious events and they will follow rules and be respectful. He asked if any research has been done on Chabad's behaviors at past locations and while he and his wife would appreciate quietness during the week, there will be noise which is distracting. Judy Lawrence spoke about noise from 1-580 which over time people get used to, said Chabad is here to be a community for Pleasanton, she hoped neighbors recognize that they want to work out things and asked that they be given this opportunity. Connie Cox spoke about Chabad's statements at meetings that they would undergo many improvements to the building and surroundings, but did not indicate this was predicated on the daycare and receipt of funds. She disagreed Chabad has been good neighbors up to this point but would like to work things out, thinks that events with 125 people would cause many traffic problems and noise, and asked that all options be explored. Merritt Wisemoth spoke of trade-offs, the fact that things change with the times, weighing of pluses and minuses, Judaism as a culture and a way of living, and protected rights under the First Amendment. Geoff Falcon spoke of his experience as a commissioner for the San Francisco Bay Area Council as a troop leader and said Troop 908 is the largest and based in Pleasanton with over 120 young men and soon to be women. Every week the troop meets at St. Clare's outdoors during the summer months in the same grass area adjacent to Chabad. He remembers no restrictions imposed, did not remember any complaints from neighbors, believes that Chabad is not a noisy group and thinks it is unfair to impose restrictions. Vascar Moty said he knew of issues with the property and noted that the Valley Trails Church was built with the neighborhood and has not restrictions. This property has restrictions and voiced opposition to the many parties and outdoor activities. He questioned what would happen if St. Clare's Church does not share their parking lot in the future and asked to respect the neighborhood impacts of noise and traffic and not allow outdoor activities. Leonard Cooper questioned why the City is restricting where, when and how he can celebrate his religion. He read the First Amendment, said Chabad is an excellent member of the community and believed the restrictions are a violation of the Constitution. Usha Gurazada, neighbor, stated she respects religious activities and thought this has to do with protection of quality of life. The City Council voted unanimously to uphold no outdoor activity and Rabbi Resnick knew that and purchased the property. She questioned how the City will protect residents' interests once approved and stated residents have been portrayed and attacked as intolerant which is disrespectful. Debra Grossman thinks what the country and Pleasanton need is civility and respect for each other, stated she has been participating in Chabad activities for 13 years and every event has been infused with learning about their faith with respect and civility. She spoke of discrimination given restrictions, stated children do not screen, and every event she has attended has had a Jewish component and also charity and survival components. EXCERPT: PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES, June 27, 2018 Page 5 of 15