20 - Laserfiche WebLink

Simon Cohen said Chabad has brought wonderful events to the entire Tri-Valley community that have enriched and educated residents. Their passion, concern and appreciation for the well-being of the valley are immeasurable and he quoted a supporter's comments. The distance of the facility relative to houses is indistinct from other preschools and churches in the area and limiting activities or restricting Chabad in any way distinct from others will awaken the entire community to fight such an injustice. He spoke of anti-Semitism and limits on freedoms, stated he lost many family members in the Holocaust and cited draconian conditions. Stan Himowitz stated the Resnick family has the highest ethics and moral values and he could not imagine they would tell anyone to move away if they do not like the facility. They are great communicators and any events have a high religious component with no drugs, alcohol or loud music, and he hoped the CUP could be approved and that people continue to respect Chabad's contribution to the Pleasanton community. Ryan Ball voiced perplexity that this daycare center is a point of contention given St. Clare's Church hosts non-religious social events for over 200 Boy Scouts weekly for 15 years. He suggested a comprehensive review of what is occurring at St. Clare's Church, stated his Jewish education and community largely comprised of Chabad has been a large part of who he is today and it would be sad if kids would not be able to have the same experiences he has benefitted from. Pierre Dutcher stated on behalf of Valley Trails residents who could not attend most of their concerns are increased traffic and noise violations. He cited arguments of unfairness as unsubstantial, said the Millers have shown the same concern about the previous groups who had caused noise outside, and said there are limitations with religious freedoms which are accepting unless they harm others. Bennett Copeland, Sunol, supported staff's recommendation, thinks if an activity was being held at Chabad when noise exceeded the code, residents could call the police as is done normally. He asked if outdoor playground noise will be enforced throughout the City, noting this will include all schools, daycare centers, and other places where kids play outside. He is a retired pediatrician and stands for children and believes restrictions were terrible to require kids be kept in a glass cage. Adam Falcon, Danville, echoed points of Geoff Falcon and Ryan Ball and stated he was once a Patrol Leader for Troop 908 and was never once alerted to any complaints or advised to be considerate of noise. Helen Princavie said she has been a neighbor of Chabad for 10 years prior to moving to Pleasanton and commented that she contacts the City Manager regularly to apprise him of her observations and never had a problem with noise. Her experience has been that there are many events and at times traffic has gotten busy, but things are always managed and people have always been polite and neighbors never complained about Chabad. Dr. Jason Belk, Livermore, stated the original restrictions were put in place for the Masonic Lodge which is not a religious congregation. He asked that the synagogue be treated equally with all other religious organizations and said freedom of religion means that one does not have to restrict their practice indoors. He noted that other religious organizations do not have EXCERPT: PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES, June 27, 2018 Page 6 of 15