7_Exhibits A, C & D - Laserfiche WebLink

Applicant Guy Houston provided closing remarks before the Public Hearing was closed. THE PUBLIC HEARING WAS CLOSED Discussion Point #1 1. Is the site appropriate for a church development? Commissioner Allen stated her initial position to likely have voted against the project but after reading the report and hearing the speakers, she thought it was appropriate as long as the rural aesthetic and traffic conditions were in place. Commissioner Gaidos agreed that it was appropriate for a church development. Commissioner Pace stated he believed the use was appropriate. Commissioner Ritter agreed with Commissioner Pace. Commissioner Nibert agreed with the other Commissioners. Chair Brown found the site appropriate for a church development and appreciated the design considerations. Discussion Point #2 2. Are the overall site plan, circulation design, and trash enclosure/delivery area layout acceptable? Commissioner Allen stated the perspective of the second story elevation of the Community Center building from Dublin Canyon Road seemed bland and requested additional articulation. She stated the Community Center felt massive and less stylish but could be mitigated with excellent screening. She stated she normally preferred parking in the back but because that was not possible, she requested screening or a design feature to shield the parking lot, similar to the Carpenter Training Center project on Santa Rita Road. Commissioner Pace stated the proposed project was well done and well laid out. He appreciated the commitment to preserving the rural character. He stated natural features were always preferable to constructed ones in a rural area. Commissioner Gaidos stated previous concerns about the trash enclosure and delivery area were appropriately addressed. He stated he liked the site design. Chair Brown stated the parking lot for the Carpenter Training Center was raised from street level, creating the need for the screening wall. He asked the grade of the parking lot to the road. Ms. Hagen stated the road coming around the corner was about 420 feet in elevation and the parking lot was 422 feet. She stated the site construction would only be two feet higher than the road and would not be noticeable. Commissioner Ritter stated he liked the site plan. He asked for clarification on the two-story Community Center building. Ms. Hagen stated there was a second-story office component and that the gym was two stories in height, although did not have a second floor. Commissioner Excerpt: Approved Planning Commission Minutes, April 14, 2021 Page 3 of 5 diversity in the City. Excerpt: Approved Planning Commission Minutes, April 14, 2021 Page 2 of 5 about 10 feet from the property line, and the church was located approximately 35 feet from the property line, providing a combined distance of approximately 45 feet between the home and the church building. She stated the sanctuary building and dome would be approximately 200 feet from the property line. Commissioner Pace asked the visual impacts and potential privacy issues. Ms. Hagen explained there were no second story windows on the west side of the building that would provide views of adjacent properties. Excerpt: Approved Planning Commission Minutes, April 14, 2021 Page 1 of 5 e type, location, and sizing calculations of the PUD-114-01M& P20-0995 Planning Commission Page 16 of 25 PUD-114-01M& P20-0995 Planning Commission Page 3 of 25 YCROSSCRISFIELD .*- 4-; -,47÷-'' 1.1--1 ''.-. HAM ;-----fk;s7,4G il 3` • kst • .7 I DIJNIYA1:1%, ..4.. ,i4is' '1 , „J 10 ,,,... ‘1 'kTIAV - 1) \ ‘ ' ?) $.Y \t, ,2:2/ \ ‘ 111-,-,: . ,..... i ..., i 1:11,343 o 0.125 0.25 mi PUD-140, Townsend, Lot Line, 2207 Martin Ave Planning Division =-- -.• .-.... , 1:16 I i II May 10,2021 FLEA:.,ANTON. 0 650 1,300 Feet