20 - Laserfiche WebLink

restrictions and asked that the Commission follow prior actions, not set limitations, and not discriminate against Jews of the Tri-Valley. Dr. Laura Silverstein, OBGYN and Vice Chair at Valley Care, said the reason her family chose to move to Pleasanton was because of the Chabad community and so their children could have an education with the preschool. She spoke of delays with her daughter being able to start pre-kindergarten with Chabad and referred to Table 1 regarding playgrounds of different religious institutions, stating Valley Church which is twice the size has no restrictions and she believed this to be unacceptable. She then referred to Item 3 on page 6 of the packet where staff indicates newer churches have more information in the CUPs; however, these have no restrictions for outdoor activities based on location or site-specific characteristics. Edward Weiss, San Ramon, spoke about the importance of teaching his family religion, said Chabad provides joy for their children and they need a synagogue where they can have community inside and outside. He has also attended Chabad functions and observed no loud noise. Steve Williams, Tri-Valley business owner, echoed comments about the Resnick's outstanding, respectful reputation, referred to the glass domes around playgrounds which he thought was ridiculous and unfair, believes all concerns will be non-issues and asked the Commission not to restrict any activities. Bella Copleton, Dublin, voiced concerns about the level of resistance, discussed traffic getting to BART in the morning and noted that another 700 units and a commercial center were being built, voiced concern with her two young children crossing a busy street to go to the park as well as the time it would take to get there, believes there was compromise to move the playground to the side of the building and thinks it is ridiculous to add a restriction to keep windows closed. She asked for approval of the project and to remove restrictions. David Silverman said a meeting was held between the two parties and neither side compromised. He thought the recommendation for a dome was not viable, stated RLUIPA laws are powerful and favor organizations like Chabad and to disregard that was unfair. He asked the Commission to move forward and approve the project. Sagir Weiss-Ishai, Alamo, questioned why there was so much disparity between Chabad and other church's restrictions which he opposed and said he works as a Fire Engineer and issues permits to daycares and preschools all the time. He also conducts decibel level studies and stated 80 dBs was nothing compared to traffic noise and would not impact neighbors. Regarding decrease in property usage, when the Miller's bought their property 30 years ago and wanted to renovate they would follow the codes, and he said Chabad was simply following these. Mark Hoffman said he recalled in April that the Commission was poised to make a decision for approval, that they agreed the previous CUP was not germane, were told that as a religious institution they should not be treated differently than any other institution and there was consensus there should be a preschool playground and an approved outdoor event area and that those conditions would be determined at today's meeting. Before the final decision was made, Commissioners asked staff to gather more information about conditions of other religious organizations and to meet again with the neighbors. He confirmed that a number of meetings have been held but neighbors want zero tolerance, and compromises were either not EXCERPT: PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES, June 27, 2018 Page 7 of 15